Skip to content

Case Study Research Design And Methods 2014 Silverado

The vehicle total life cycle

In October 2015, we released a study, “A New Paradigm in Automotive Mass Benchmarking,” which provided insights into the lightweighting of production model vehicles. Since then, we conducted a follow up Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) case study, the focus of this article. LCA is a methodology that considers a vehicle’s entire life cycle, from the manufacturing stage (including material production and vehicle assembly) through the use stage (including production and combustion of fuel) to the end of life (EOL) stage (including end of life disposal and recycling).

What were the findings of the initial study?

Using statistical benchmarking methodology developed by Dr. Don Malen,, research scientist University of Michigan, we identified the most efficient (the lightest for the same size and performance) designs from a database of over 200 production vehicles. In our initial study, we compared efficient steel and efficient aluminium components for doors, hoods, hatchbacks, decklids and bumpers. Interestingly, we uncovered some startling findings:

  • There is a wide variation in efficiency among steel components in vehicles on the road today.
  • When aluminium closure components, such as doors, bumpers, hatchbacks, and decklids, are compared to efficient steel components of similar size and performance, the 40 percent mass savings currently accepted as a standard measure of aluminium lightweighting capability is not nearly reached.
  • While use of aluminium may achieve mass savings at the component level, that mass savings is lost when an entire system is measured.

What were the findings of our follow-up case study that considered a vehicle total life cycle?

Using data and mass estimation models from the initial study, we next investigated the life cycle GHG impact of three principal categories of material usage in the Body Structure subsystems for A/B vehicle class cars that were represented in the vehicle benchmarking data (provided by A2Mac1, a global benchmarking company.) The following are the three categories of material usage we examined:

  1. An average steel design;
  2. An efficient steel design based on 17 of the most efficient body structures in the database;
  3. An efficient aluminium design, which was derived from the most efficient aluminium structures.

The results of the LCA case study show that the aluminium body structure, though lighter, will result in a +1% increase in GHG emissions over its total life cycle. The steel body structure would result in a -1% decrease in GHG emissions.

Why? If a weight savings is achieved, shouldn’t the car be more environmentally efficient?

This question highlights the reason LCA is so important to improving vehicle environmental performance. Because the primary production of steel emits seven times less GHG emissions than aluminium, vehicles made of steel, using efficient, optimized designs, may be lower in emissions when considering the vehicle total life cycle.

Following are our results in an infographic summary (click the image to enlarge). Download the Case Study to review all parameters that we used in the model and the detailed results. The estimation of life cycle GHG emissions was conducted using the UCSB Automotive Materials Energy Model, which can be downloaded freely. The UCSB Model was designed to quantify the energy and GHG impacts of automotive material substitution on a total vehicle life cycle basis, under a broad range of conditions and in a completely transparent fashion. The Model has been peer-reviewed and uses current data for material emissions and other parameters.

CLICK TO ENLARGE

Primary Entity

# Case study research : design and methods
    a schema:CreativeWork, schema:Book ;
library:oclcnum "835951262" ;
library:placeOfPublication ;
schema:about ; # Sciences sociales
schema:about ; # Social sciences--Research--Methodology
schema:about ; # Manuels
schema:about ;
schema:about ; # Méthodologie
schema:about ; # Social Sciences--methods
schema:about ; # Etudes de cas
schema:about ; # Research methods
schema:about ; # Case studies
schema:about ; # Fallmethode
schema:about ; # Social sciences--Research--Methodology
schema:about ; # Case method
schema:about ; # Methodology
schema:about ; # Méthodes de recherche
schema:about ; # Research Design
schema:about ; # Manuals
schema:about ; # Empirische Sozialforschung
schema:about ; # Social sciences
schema:about ; # Sozialwissenschaften
schema:author ; # Robert K. Yin
schema:bookEdition "Fifth edition." ;
schema:bookFormatbgn:PrintBook ;
schema:datePublished "2014" ;
schema:description "Providing a complete portal to the world of case study research, the Fifth Edition of Robert K. Yin's bestselling text offers comprehensive coverage of the design and use of the case study method as a valid research tool. The book offers a clear definition of the case study method as well as discussion of design and analysis techniques. The Fifth Edition has been updated with nine new case studies, three new appendices, seven tutorials presented at the end of relevant chapters, increased coverage of values and ethics, expanded discussion on logic models, a brief glossary, and completely updated citations. This book includes exemplary case studies drawn from a wide variety of academic fields."@en ;
schema:description "Getting started : how to know whether and when to use the case study as a research method -- Designing case studies : identifying your case(s) and establishing the logic of your case study -- Preparing to collect case study evidence : what you need to do before starting to collect case study data -- Collecting case study evidence : the principles you should follow in working with six sources of evidence -- Analyzing case study evidence : how to start your analysis, your analytic choices, and how they work -- Reporting case studies : how and what to compose -- Appendix A.A note on the uses of case study research in psychology -- Appendix B.A note on the uses of case study research in evaluations -- Appendix C. Index of individual case studies (cited in BOXES or from expanded case study materials)."@en ;
schema:exampleOfWork ;
schema:inLanguage "en" ;
schema:name "Case study research : design and methods"@en ;
schema:productID "835951262" ;
schema:workExample ;
wdrs:describedby ;
    .


Related Entities


    a schema:Intangible ;
    .

# Case studies
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Case studies"@en ;
    .

# Empirische Sozialforschung
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Empirische Sozialforschung"@en ;
    .

# Etudes de cas
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Etudes de cas"@en ;
    .

# Fallmethode
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Fallmethode"@en ;
    .

# Manuals
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Manuals"@en ;
    .

# Manuels
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Manuels"@en ;
    .

# Méthodes de recherche
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Méthodes de recherche"@en ;
    .

# Méthodologie
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Méthodologie"@en ;
    .

# Research Design
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Research Design"@en ;
    .

# Research methods
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Research methods"@en ;
    .

# Sciences sociales
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Sciences sociales"@en ;
    .

# Social Sciences--methods
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Social Sciences--methods"@en ;
    .

# Sozialwissenschaften
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Sozialwissenschaften"@en ;
    .

# Social sciences--Research--Methodology
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Social sciences--Research--Methodology"@en ;
    .


    a schema:Place ;
dcterms:identifier "cau" ;
    .

# Methodology
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Methodology"@en ;
    .

# Social sciences
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Social sciences"@en ;
    .

# Social sciences--Research--Methodology
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Social sciences--Research--Methodology"@en ;
    .

# Case method
    a schema:Intangible ;
schema:name "Case method"@en ;
    .

# Robert K. Yin
    a schema:Person ;
schema:familyName "Yin" ;
schema:givenName "Robert K." ;
schema:name "Robert K. Yin" ;
    .


    a schema:ProductModel ;
schema:isbn "1452242569" ;
schema:isbn "9781452242569" ;
    .


    a genont:InformationResource, genont:ContentTypeGenericResource ;
schema:about ; # Case study research : design and methods
schema:dateModified "2018-03-13" ;
void:inDataset ;
    .


Content-negotiable representations